 |
Under U.S. law, the dead cannot be defamed. However, those in their shadow—particularly family members or associates connected to alleged misdeeds—may still pursue legal action if they believe their own reputations have been harmed.
While there's always the time-honored writerly approach of simply waiting for problematic subjects to pass away, most writers need more immediate guidance.This article offers practical strategies for minimizing legal risk when writing about the deceased and those who survive them.
Defamation requires you to check four boxes: (1) a false statement of fact, (2) publication to a third party, (3) identification of the person or entity, and (4) resulting harm to reputation. Constitutional defamation law balances reputation protection with First Amendment free speech rights.The level of fault required depends primarily on whether the plaintiff is a public figure, limited-purpose public figure, or private figure. Public figures must prove actual malice (knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for truth), while private figures generally need only prove negligence, though some states require actual malice even for private figures when the speech involves matters of public concern. Media defendants may receive additional constitutional protections in certain contexts. Truth serves as a complete defense against defamation claims.
1. Know the Legal Limits. If a defamation lawsuit is filed before a person’s death, their estate may continue to pursue the claim after they’ve passed away. This is because the legal cause of action was already initiated while the individual was alive, and it becomes part of the estate’s assets. The estate essentially steps into the shoes of the deceased for purposes of continuing the litigation.
2. Survivors Can Sue: If your portrayal of the deceased indirectly harms the reputation of a living person who stood in the deceased's shadow—such as a spouse, child, or business associate—they may have grounds for a defamation or false light claim. False light claims don't require proving falsity—they focus on whether the portrayal, while possibly true, creates a misleading impression that would be highly offensive to a reasonable person.
3. Fictionalize with Care. Fictionalizing in a memoir or difficult personal story can be appropriate to convey emotional truths, protect privacy, or clarify events without compromising the story’s integrity. Keep in mind that courts consider whether a person is identifiable, not just named. So, beyond changing names, you must alter identifying details to prevent readers from reasonably linking characters to real people. Transparency about fictionalization—through prefatory notes or disclaimers—is crucial. Most importantly, fictionalization should never distort or misrepresent key facts that would alter the story’s overall truth or message.
4. Use Disclaimers Strategically. While not bulletproof, a prominent disclaimer stating that your work is fiction or that certain elements are fictionalized may help deter claims by the living.
5. Truth Is Your Best Defense. If you’re writing nonfiction, verify all factual claims. Verifiable truth is an absolute defense to defamation, so keep keep your documentation in an accessible place in case your work is challenged.
6. Watch for Criminal Libel Statutes. A handful of states, including Colorado and Georgia, have criminal libel laws that allow prosecution for statements that “blacken the memory” of the dead. While these laws are seldom enforced, and have faced constitutional challenges due to free speech protections, they still pose a risk in sensitive cases.
###
Related Articles
DISCLAIMER / TERMS OF USE
Not Legal Advice. The information contained in this blog is intended as general advice. Because the law is not static, and one situation may differ from the next, we cannot assume responsibility for any actions taken based on information published here. Be aware that the law may vary from state to state. Therefore, this blog cannot replace the advice of an experienced attorney. No attorney-client relationship is created by your access to or use of this website. Contacting us by email does not create an attorney-client relationship. If you wish to establish a professional relationship, it must be done through a mutual agreement in writing. Please do not send us any confidential information until an attorney-client relationship has been established.
Attorney Advertising. While intended as general advice, this blog and its contents may be considered attorney advertising under the rules of certain jurisdictions. Hiring an attorney is an important decision and should not be based solely on advertising. Past results are no guarantee of future results.
Limitation of Liability. We disclaim any liability, loss, damage, injury, or cost (including, without limitation, attorneys' fees, lost profits, or data) caused by the contents of this blog or website.
Links. This website contains links to third-party websites and other resources. These links are provided solely for your convenience and for educational purposes. They should not be construed as endorsements by the Law Offices of Lloyd J. Jassin.
Jurisdiction. Using this website, you have irrevocably agreed to the U.S. federal and state courts' sole and exclusive jurisdiction and venue in New York City, USA. Any action, suit, or proceeding involving the use of this website, the information contained in this website, to the extent permitted by federal law, will be governed by the laws of the State of New York (excluding New York's choice of law rules) in the absence of applicable federal law.
